marmot minimalist jacket vs patagonia torrentshellmarmot minimalist jacket vs patagonia torrentshell
Photo by Robert Curzon. A jackets ability to keep you cool is greatly enhanced with the inclusion of pit zips, which we discuss further below. Youll want to have room for a warm layer (such as a light fleece jacket) underneath, but little additional extra room. Firstly, Patagonia is more focused on the environment than North Face. For fast-and-light alpine trips when the forecast looks favorable, the Highline certainly can do the trick. While this is great, its doesnt necessarily mean the jacket is that packable. At $185, the Downpour Plus 2.0 slides in between popular rain jackets like the Patagonia Torrentshell above and Marmot Minimalist below. If you value comfort and stretchiness in a rain jacket, its pretty ideal. The Patagonia Storm10 gives the Arcteryx Beta LT above a run for its money as our top performance pick, but in the end, the two jackets have slightly different intentions. Your jacket will stop being able to breatheand all that moisture next to your skin is there to stay. Youll see this referenced in every performance-oriented rain jacket on the market, typically seen as: 2L, 2.5L or 3L. Price - $149. But for normal hiking and backpacking, its often prudent to avoid this feature as the large hood will require a lot of cinching down, causing the fabrics to bunch up. What we don't: A bit crinkly and stiff; no chest pocket. You might also like: The Best Rain Jackets Under $50 Material and Other Details. You also get pit zips for dumping heat and a higher-quality hood with better adjustability, which are worthwhile upgrades for most hikers. Tack on sleek Patagonia styling, wide variety of available colorways, new-for-2023 PFC-free DWR coating (to go along with the 100%-recycled face fabric), and excellent $179 price tag, and the versatile Torrentshell 3L currently is our favorite overall rain jacket. As a general recommendation, the following works well for us: Wash the jacket in warm water with liquid detergent, and run it through a second rinse cycle to clear out any detergent residue. And (no surprise), 2.5-layer jackets are a heckuva lot more lightweight and affordable than most full 3-layer jackets. We mentioned that the XeroDry is a great value, and for reference, the next-most-affordable Paclite models are Marmot's Minimalist at $199 and ORs Foray II above at $225. That said, this model introduces some features that add to the jackets versatility. Category: PerformanceWeight: 14.5 oz.Waterproofing: 2.5L Gore-Tex Paclite PlusWhat we like: Durable shell with premium waterproofing.What we dont: Relatively heavy and bulky. Professional reviewers raved about the REI XeroDry GTX. What changed? With any luck, youll have sunny weather for most of your fun outside. The 10-denier fabric of the Versalite means this jacket won't be the one you turn to outside of thru-hiking or ultralight backpacking. Typically done with a cord and toggle, theyre very user-friendly. . FREE delivery Wed, Mar 8 . OStill, this is a budget hiking jacket for a reason: everyday reviewers across Amazon, Backcountry, and REI said that the Marmot PreCip Eco isnt a jacket for downpourswith some reviewers pointing the finger at the new DWR coating. Of note: This article includes picks for both men and women, but weve also written a dedicated round-up on the best womens rain jackets. At Treeline, we want you to buy right the first time. Three of our five picks have armpit zips (we decided to split the difference with the name), which are great for keeping you cool in warmer weather. Admittedly, some customer reviews found that it feels a little insulated. Like the Marmot PreCip Eco and REI Co-op Rainier above, the TNF features a 2.5-layer construction (in this case, their in-house DryVent design), pit zips for ventilation, and an adjustable hood. Enter the pit zip. The OR Helium, in contrast, uses a 30 denier to achieve a jacket of the same weight (but again, no pockets or pit zips). Category: Daily useWeight: 13 oz.Waterproofing: 2L Omni-TechWhat we like: Great value, lots of color options.What we dont: Cheap construction has a plasticky feel. However, in the light rain shell jacket, $60 to . In addition, the single side waist adjuster means the jacket feels uneven when pulled tight. So while it could be that those reviewers actually got wet, it could just be that the rain jacket they were using started to wet outthat is, the outer fabric started to absorb (rather than repel) the rain. Still, it seemed to work well enough in conjunction with the superior breathability of the Gore Tex Paclite over proprietary waterproofing materials. But Patagonia upped their game with the Torrentshell 3L (see review above ), a more-adjustable helmet-compatible hood, top-of-the-line waterproofing, higher eco-standards, and a price . Marmot Minimalist: REI Co-op XeroDry GTX: Marmot PreCip Eco: Water Resistance (30%) 8.0. They go as far as detailing the sustainable steps theyve made, as well as calling out where they come up short at the bottom of their product pages. This is unheard of at this weight for any other rain jacket, including the Outdoor Research Helium. And as weve come to expect from the brand, all of the Beta LTs details are nicely sorted, with premium seam taping, streamlined seams, and a fit that is reasonably trim but roomy enough for layering. For those who value reflective detail, The North Face made a point to add reflective features on the front and back of the jacket. The latest rain jacket from the Patagonia brand sports a 3-layer construction, giving it a big boost in performance. This jacket is protective, well made, and has the zealous flair for aesthetic style that makes Patagonia more than just an outdoor brand. The Venture 2 Hooded Jacket is one of The North Face's most popular waterproof jackets, for good reason. Our Patagonia Women's Torrentshell 3L Jacket has a trusted reputation for providing exceptional waterproof/breathable performance, comfort and durability. Based in Salt Lake City, Cotopaxi is a relatively new brand that has quickly risen to popularity in the outdoor world, thanks to their sustainable business practices, positive community presence, andof coursehard-to-miss colorways. Photo by Liz Thomas. For a similar concept but with a more durable, around-town-friendly build, check out TNFs Resolve 2Read in-depth reviewSee the Men's The North Face Venture 2 See the Women's The North Face Venture 2. Depending on what your jacket is made of and the care you put into its maintenance, it can last for years. Patagonia Torrentshell 3L Jacket. The test is a strange one: It doesnt mimic real-world conditions and many manufacturers choose not to list it at all. In fact, the packable rain jacket was originally created to keep the jacket clean and the membrane free from oils and dirt that reduce breathability. Best Environmentally-Friendly Rain Jacket. 2.5-Layer If you do a lot of night running or running in low-light conditions, see our Best Reflective Running Gear List for accessories that can augment the reflective details of any of the running jackets we recommend. Both the Marmot PreCip Eco and the Outdoor Research Helium are 2.5-layer jackets. For those looking to carry their rain jacket in a running belt or running vest, and potentially racing with them, the FutureLight Rain jacket is also tailored to balance packability and weight while keeping you dry. Here in the Pacific Northwest, we know a thing or two about rain. Layer 1 is the shell (aka face fabric), usually made of nylon or polyester. A utilitarian men's rain jacket: Columbia Men's . Marmot Minimalist. Some rain jackets offer pit zips and/or full side vents, while basic models do not (as well as taped seams on more expensive rain jackets for extra protection from the elements). Daily use/hiking: 3L H2No: 50D: Yes: Patagonia Calcite: $249: . Take time out of your adventures to adequately dry your rain jacket after it gets wet, when you can. Cons: Only two length options. One downside? The Highline sticks to BDs roots with a climbing helmet-compatible hood (its too small for a standard ski helmet) and includes useful features like pit zips, hand pockets, and a tall collar. Wash your rain jacket according to the manufacturers instructionsmost prefer it if you avoid using detergent, though something like NikWax Tech Wash helps to restore the fabric. In addition, you miss out on a chest pocket, and the shell isnt a weight or packed size leader. Its easy to layer a puffy underneath, but the jacket was much too long and roomy for us when wearing it over a thin baselayer. Another potential explanation is that those reviewers simply werent ventilating enoughand the water that they feel is really their own sweat, not rain. Men's Minimalist Jacket. Pocket placement is another consideration. When saving weight is critical to your mission, choose the Marmot Minimalist jacket. The GORE . The Marmot Minimalist features good quality, clean style, and an all-around rain jacket. But while it offers all the performance most hikers need, its simplified design does make a few sacrifices. 22 February 2021 by nadia. Lets talk about sleeves and sleeve cuffs for a sec. Be sure to bring your hands to shoulder height to test how far the sleeves ride up while youre moving. We create reader-supported, objective gear reviews independently selected by our editors. Arc'teryx has used its extensive knowledge in waterproofing technology to create a lightweight and feature-packed rain jacket. The Torrentshell 3L tops our list with its impressively balanced design, but for a step up in performance its worth checking out the Calcite here. Patagonia has also added another zipper to their pit zips, meaning more customizable ventilation and easier zipping and unzipping. All rights reserved. Climbing. Read More: Work from Home like an Outdoor Writer. Instead, it protects Layer 2 (aka the waterproof-breathable membrane) from the dirt, sweat, oil, and abrasion that causes it to degrade over time. Combining 3-layer Gore-Tex construction with a host of technical features (including a helmet-compatible hood and pit zips), the Beta LT blurs the line between rain jacket and hardshell and delivers trustworthy performance for four-season hiking and backcountry exploring. The North Face Lightriser Futurelight is a running jacket is the most breathable running rain jacket we found. Hood sizes and cinches are a small feature that can make a big difference on a rain jacket. The beading seems to continue forever. Generally, companies split outdoor apparel lines into womens models and mens models-and while that doesnt quite mesh with our understanding of gender diversity, the outdoor industry hasnt quite yet caught up with reality. Treeline writer Tiffany Searsdodd (on left) takes the Marmot Minimalist on skis. Additionally, we have a whole section on waterproofing in our Best Mens Ski Jackets and Best Women's Ski Jackets guide. 3-Layer Shop All Men's Multi-Sport Rain Jackets. The half layer is printed onto the second layer, sometimes appearing as a cool pattern along the inside of your jacket. That half-layer isnt quite as good as a full-out third layer at protecting your second layer membrane. Youll feel damp, clammy, and likely a little peeved at your rain jacket. (Sensing a trend?) The Marmot Minimalist jacket caught my eye late last year. The men's and women's Black Diamond Stormline Stretch is our winner for Best Stretchy Rain Jacket. Category: Daily use/hikingWeight: 10.6 oz.Waterproofing: 2.5L NanoProWhat we like: Proven performance for a great price.What we dont: Feels more plasticky than many of the more modern jackets here. Full unzipped, the jacket becomes a poncho. BLACK-DIAMOND: Extra 20% off Outlet with coupon code "OUTLET20". It's fully seam taped. A jackets packability can be looked at and measured in a couple ways. In addition, the REI has a slightly more substantial face fabric and improved comfort with a fleece-like lining covering the collar (weight goes up a bit as a result). Heres the story: This hardshell-like design includes a 3-layer variation of their in-house BD.dry membrane, has a light amount of stretch incorporated into the nylon build, and keeps things pretty light at 12.7 ounces (our mens medium is slightly more at 12.8 oz.). Specs. Considering a deluge, or planning long hours out in the rain? Hood size can be a big consideration when rain jacket shopping. We love what Outdoor Research has done with the Foray (and womens Aspire), a do-it-all rain jacket that can even work as a lightweight shell for spring skiing. Similarly, the Patagonia Torrentshell 3L is said to start at 20,000 mm-though after their Killer Wash treatment, which simulates what they presume to be years of heavy use, that degrades down to about 10,000 mm. Lets start with layers, what they do, and why they matter. The chest pockets shape has changed from rectangular to curvierand it will no longer fit larger phone models. Make sure you think about whats best for you before you buy. All our recommended jackets will excel for hiking and backpacking, but if you're bike commuting, we'd recommend something by a dedicated bike brand like Showers Pass. Breathable: Jack Wolfskin JWP. Popular applications include backcountry skiing and trekking in mild weather. One standout is Arcteryxs StormHood (as seen on the Beta LT): With a single pull at the back of the hood, you adjust evenly around the sides and back of the head. Reproduction without permission is prohibited. A longstanding favorite in the rain shell market, Marmots Minimalist balances classy looks with solid Gore-Tex protection. The winner, the Patagonia Torrentshell 3L, was one of the less expensive ones at $149. 4.0 4.0 out of 5 stars (36) $196.42 $ 196. Jackets in this category include the Arc'teryx Beta LT, which impressed us with its performance during a wet and slushy winter in the PNW. You wont often see add-ons like helmet-compatible hoods or exposed, water-resistant zippers in this category, and daily use jackets dont prioritize weight-savings or packability (in fact, theyre often quite thick and durable). MARMOT. Having pit zips or pockets whose backs are made of mesh can vent some of your excess heat in warm weather. Theyre not very breathable and the mesh adds bulk, making 2-layer jackets best for casual use. And while we didnt see any issues about ventilation, it doesn't have pit zips either. Category: Performance/hikingWeight: 13.9 oz.Waterproofing: 3L Gore-TexWhat we like: Strong combination of weight-savings, protection, and performance-oriented features.What we dont: The priciest rain jacket on our list at $450. Category: HikingWeight: 6.4 oz.Waterproofing: 2L Gore InfiniumWhat we like: Great combination of weight and breathability.What we dont: Compromises in protection and durability, and its not an around-town piece. 45. Three names, two zippers, one delightful function: keeping you just a little cooler. The 2.5-layer shell is softer and more pliable than most 3-layer designs here, and Pertex Shield has a long track record for being hardwearing and weather-protective. A lightweight jacket will better serve you in multiple situations from hiking through an autumn storm to tossing in a suitcase to travel. Despite the Gore Tex Paclite's superior breathability, that's a feature we still want. . For example, the REI XeroDry GTX is a true 2-layer jacket made with Gore-Tex PacLite Plus technology. Most negative consumer reviews we saw for every jacket we reviewed had to do with the reviewer getting wet some way or another. One of our favorites is the Patagonia Torrentshell Jacket (click here for best deal).The Torrentshell is a very simple-looking jacket but it has some very cool features that make . They have everything from rain suits to a rain poncho to an ultralight, permanently waterproof jacket. You decide. It is a great jacket to have if you are going to be in persistent wind or rain. Category: Hiking/daily useWeight: 10.9 oz.Waterproofing: 3L AscentShellWhat we like: Lightweight, breathable, and a good price.What we dont: Missing some useful features like wrist cinches and hipbelt-friendly pockets. A fresh DWR is an impressive thing and can offer excellent protection in light to moderate conditions, although heavy and sustained rainfall will eventually overwhelm the coating (thats where the waterproof membrane comes into play). We recommend sleeves that are slightly longer than youd try to get for a normal shirt, to give some weather protection to your hands. DWR repels oil, grease, water, dirt, and whatever else you encounter on your adventure. Enter the drawcord hem. Its versatility in a number of conditions--rain, wind, and hanging out--make it a smart choice if you only own one rain jacket. These downsides are enough to drop the XeroDry a bit on our list, but we still like its combination of features, Gore-Tex membrane, and price Read in-depth reviewSee the Men's REI XeroDry GTX See the Women's REI XeroDry GTX. Arcteryx has traditionally lagged behind here, but some of their recent releases have begun incorporating these best-known practices. Its one of only a few Gore Tex Pac Lite plus jackets on our list and normally, namebrand waterproofing like Gore Tex costs a premium. The REI XeroDry GTX comes in at 28,000+ mm and is rated for multiple days of rain. We had days of 35 F with steady rain-and I had no water intrusion at all. She also thought it was great at keeping out cold gusts of wind along the way. Now I know the Marmot is a GTX PacLite 2.5 which means it's very reliant on its DWR performance. Avoid over washing, as that can cause damage, tooyoull want to wash once every several uses. Its a membrane, which is coated or laminated and layered under the face fabric. The other way of looking at packable rain shells is how compressible they truly are. Learn more. Yes: Patagonia Torrentshell 3L: $149: 12.5 oz. We're thrilled that for 2023, there was competition for this category (such as the Outdoor Research Heliumwhich is a good option if you want something less expensive). Your jacket isn't as waterproof or breathable as it should be. It has all of the features most-often sought after in a rain jacket - including armpit zips, fully-lined hand pockets, and the ability to pack down into a pocket. Released last year, the Arcteryx Beta offers a nice middle ground for those who want the premium weather protection of the Beta LT above alongside a more casual feature set. It was a little different from many other jackets in the same rain shell category in that it was made from Gore-tex. Elastic cuffs arent ideal: when the rain runs down your arms, it gets wicked directly onto your hands, regardless of the length of your sleeves. Our line of technical shells offers pinnacle waterproof, yet breathable protection for every activity. All three of these jackets check in around 13 to 14 ounces and come with pit zips, but the Rab stands out with its smooth-operating coated zippers (the aforementioned jackets instead feature storm flaps) and trimmer fit. If you want to save some money and be protected in most wet weather conditions, this is a good pick. Secondly, Patagonia products usually cost a little bit more than North Face products. Some complain its too large, others that its too small, still others that its just right - so use your discretion when buying. The most notable update was the inclusion of Pertexs Diamond Fuse fabric, which boosts durability and tear resistance without a weight penalty. You dont get a ton of room for layering (we can fit a thin midlayer underneath, but not much more), and the low weight and streamlined feature set makes it one of our favorite emergency layers. You can read more about how waterproofing and breathability ratings work here. Reasonable weather protection for drier climates. More on this in waterproofing below. . By opening up the jacket under the arms, you can release a lot of air without sacrificing the jackets waterproof design. Its not that any of these features is a dealbreaker, but rather, you have to decide what you must haveand what you could do withoutbefore going hunting for a jacket. But we think the vast majority of folks will find the Torrentshell to be a near-perfect match for everyday and light backcountry use. ", 42F and dumping rain, running alongside the creek and Juniper Pines in the Eastern Sierra in The North Face Lightriser. This measurement tests both general water repellency as well as performance under pressure. There are several criteria worth considering when getting a rain jacket, mostly to do with the features of that jacket. A few rain jackets on this list cross into the lighter end of the hardshell category, including the Outdoor Research Motive, Rab Kinetic Alpine 2.0, and Arc'teryx Beta LT. A rain jackets waterproofing relies on a combination of factors: durable water repellent (DWR) coating that beads up water, and clean fabric layers on either side of the waterproof and breathable membrane to allow air vapor to pass through. We get down into the step-by-step of caring for waterproof shells in our article on How to Clean and Repair Gore-Tex and Other Shells. Some manufacturers succeed better than others at this concept. Here, the Patagonia Torrentshell is shown zipped up alongside a waterbottle to give perspective. Mesh pockets allow for a little extra ventilation and are better for warm weather. For comparison's sake, our top-ranked Patagonia Torrentshell 3L weighs 12.4 ounces and is about 1.5 times the size of the Norrna when packed into its pocket. Performance & security by Cloudflare. And last we checked, it was out of stock. MARMOT NanoPro. 48. Weight: 11.3 oz (mens)/ 9.5 oz (womens), What we liked: mobility, sleek look, ventilation, pockets, packability, What we didn't like: not as waterproof or breathable as other jackets. It reminds us of similar Gore Tex jackets that are twice-the-price, such ArcTeryx jackets we tested. Finally, we've had consistent issues with the jacket wetting out fairly quickly in heavy rainfall (it's also slow to dry). Customer Service Hours: Mon-Fri, 9AM - 5PM EST. The Patagonia Torrentshell jacket offers top-quality performance. But we do appreciate Cotopaxis effort towards sustainably built outerwear, and their rain jacket is undeniably good-looking for a budget piece. Diagonal reflective stripes now adorn the sleeves for better visibility in the dark. Its not quite as durable as the Torrentshell, but the Downpour is the sleeker and more packable design and more fine-tuned for performance use. Best Performance Balance: Marmot Minimalist Rain Jacket. The OR Helium also doesn't have as good of a waterproofing or breathability rating as the Versalite. When you click on the links to purchase gear, we may get a commission, without costing you an extra cent. The ultimate expression of how effective a pit zip can be is the Outdoor Research Foray II. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. That final point wasnt a deal breaker for us but is a downside for everyday wear.See the Men's Rab Downpour Plus 2.0 See the Women's Rab Downpour Plus 2.0. If youre looking to use this jacket to commuteout in the rain a bit, into the warm and dry a bitany of these lightweight jackets will do for you (though we think with its balance of price, durability, and comfort, youll like the Patagonia Torrentshell 3L the best). It's worth noting that nearly all premium performance jackets to make our list have a 3-layer construction. These jackets are the most basic, and typically require a mesh liner to protect the jackets inner coating (hence the 2-layer name). Everything from the REIs hood design to pocket layout and even smaller touches like mesh pockets and the Velcro covering the center zipper reminded us of the Marmot shell. $59 - $179 (1) Patagonia PowSlayer Jacket Snowsport Jacket / Waterproof $346 - $699 (1) Rab Phantom Waterproof Pull-On . When the wind is blowing, you want a hood that conforms to your head, while retaining enough structure around the sides and the bill that you can still see out. Keep that in mind, and youre likely to be happier with any rain jacket you purchase. It was our previous overall winner, but given the value of the newer 3-layer more-waterproof Patagonia Torrentshell, we think it's a better choice for most folks who are ok living without the additional stretch of this Black Diamond jacket. It may be tempting to go with the super-budget ultralight rain jacket: men's and women's Frogg Toggs rain gear. The nearly-always-on-sale Marmot PreCip Eco will get you through that commute, light rain shower, or brief rain. Plus, the 2023 version has some of the most inclusive sizing of any rain jacket we considered. Warranty Related Issues: 1-888-311-2900, Mon-Fri, 12PM - 4PM EST The elastic shock cord and tensioning piece are minimal but not finicky; they stay out of the way when needing to cinch the hood tightly over your face for maximum weather protection. Waterproofing measures waterproofing and soak-through over a 24-hour period. $77 - $250 (4) Arc'teryx Squamish Hoody. Overall Performance Treeline writer Felicia Hermosillo in the Frogg Toggs rain jacket in the Sierra. Torrentshell is made of 100% Ripstop Nylon, which is highly resistant against water and wind.The H2No 2.5L Performance Standard shell is what actually gives this jacket its extended weather-protection qualities and also slightly helps with breathability.. With its 50D ripstop nylon shell, the Patagonia Torrentshell 3L is one of the more robust budget-friendly models. To start, the cuffs sit awkwardly around your hands: Theyre too loose to create a good seal and would benefit from a Velcro cinch. On the other hand, weve seen what can happen to rain jackets after a few hard seasons of mechanical wear from scrunching. Because adding pit zips to a jacket inevitably results in a slight weight increase, some manufacturers like REI, Rab, and Outdoor Research have come up with a creative solution: core vents. Thatll leave more room for your do. What else is new in this model? Photo by Robert Curzon. Our testers love the Stormline Stretch for its comfort. But uses and budgets vary, and the ideal A great pair of hiking pants provides comfort, freedom of movement, the versatility to perform well in a range of environments, and durability over the long haul. Seriously, a nod to the fashion conscious. There are two reasons to clean your rain jacket. As with most of their offerings, Cotopaxi did something a little different with the Cielo, and we really like the result. We only want the same thing as youthe best gear at the best price. . That incredible lightness of being comes from a lack of the usual features: the Helium has no armpit zips for ventilation and no hand pockets, though there is a chest pocket that the jacket can pack down into. Your IP: Check out the Marmot Men's Minimalist Jacket at Enwild: https://www.enwild.com/marmot-mens-minimalist-jacket-2022.html?utm_source=youtube.com&utm_medium=desc. The one complaint we have about the REI XeroDry GTX is while it has two hand pockets, it doesnt pack down into either of them. Thats why ventilation and breathability are clutch when it comes to a rain jackets performance. Patagonia Calcite Jacket - Weight and Packability. So what does it mean when your jacket is 2.5-layer? Category: PerformanceWeight: 12.7 oz.Waterproofing: 3L BD.dryWhat we like: A stretchy and light performance shell at a good price.What we dont: Less bombproof and versatile than a Gore-Tex design. But it does prevent some dirt, oil, and abrasion from degrading the efficacy of your jacket. If youre in the market for a casual shell for light drizzles or quick dashes between the car and the climbing gym, the Cielo fits the part.See the Men's Cotopaxi Cielo See the Women's Cotopaxi Cielo. My old torrentshell despite maintaining with recommended DWR reapplication; constantly wet through on the shoulders and was stifling in high humidity. Designs like Outdoor Researchs Motive and Black Diamonds StormLine and FineLine incorporate fabrics and a waterproof internal membrane that flex surprisingly easily. As we trek to higher ground, we open the underarm vents to keep our microclimate calm, while the hood's laminated visor diverts the sky's steady stream away from our eyes. The adjustable cuffs on the new model are half elastic, on the other side of the wrist, and half velcro. Fabric: 50D ripstop . 639 Reviews. Its just not as natural a landing spot for your hands. That does mean, however, that your rain jacket will likely spend most of its time in your backpack or bag.
